Choose Nearest City

  • Calgary
  • Ottawa
  • Edmonton
  • Regina
  • Halifax
  • Saskatoon
  • Hamilton
  • Toronto GTA
  • Kingston
  • Vancouver
  • Kitchener
  • Waterloo
  • London
  • Windsor
  • Montreal
  • Winnipeg
  • Outside of Canada

Choose your city (or nearest city)

  • Calgary
  • Montreal
  • Edmonton
  • Ottawa
  • Regina
  • Saskatoon
  • Halifax
  • Toronto GTA
  • Hamilton
  • Vancouver
  • Kingston
  • Waterloo
  • Kitchener
  • Windsor
  • London
  • Winnipeg
  • Outside of Canada
  • Events
  • Directory
  • PatronsPatrons

Enter your login credentials

Forgot username?

Forgot password?

Remember Me
Register
Facebook Login Google Login
loading
Please wait, logging in...

Register Details

[Form copy_BFRegistration not found!]
Have an account? Login

Forgot Username

[Form forgot_username not found!]

Forgot Password

[Form forgot_password not found!]

How would you like to proceed?

LOG IN / SIGN UP allows you to:
  • Have a record of all events you've been to.
  • Request cancellation if you cannot make it to an event.
  • Post an event of your own.
  • Add your business/organization listing to the online directory.
  • Add an opportunity (job, volunteer, petition, survey, etc.).

Please login to continue

LOG IN / SIGN UP allows you to:
  • Have a record of all events you've been to.
  • Request cancellation if you cannot make it to an event.
  • Post an event of your own.
  • Add your business/organization listing to the online directory.
  • Add an opportunity (job, volunteer, petition, survey, etc.).
Muslim Link is Ottawa Muslims' Online Community Newspaper. The site includes an up-to-date Events Listing and Business and Community Directory for Ottawa Muslims.
.
ML Directory
ML Directory
  • Home
  • Events
    • Ottawa
    • Montreal
    • Toronto GTA
    • Edmonton
    • Calgary
    • Vancouver
    • London
    • Windsor
    • Hamilton
    • Halifax
    • Winnipeg
    • Kingston
    • Kitchener/Waterloo
    • Regina/Saskatoon
    • Event Table
  • Directory
    • Ottawa
    • Montreal
    • Toronto GTA
    • Edmonton
    • Calgary
    • Vancouver
    • London
    • Windsor
    • Hamilton
    • Halifax
    • Winnipeg
    • Kingston
    • Kitchener/Waterloo
    • Regina/Saskatoon
  • News
  • Stories
  • Islamic Finance
  • Classifieds
    • Opportunities
      • Volunteer Opportunities
      • Job Opportunities
      • Crowdfunding
      • Bazaar Vendors Wanted
      • Call for Donations
      • ​​Scholarships / Bursaries
      • ​​Petitions
      • Nominations
      • ​​Call for Participants
      • ​​Call for Submissions
      • Call for Abstracts
      • Grants
      • ​​Surveys
      • ​​Invitation to Dialogue
      • Sponsorships
      • Contests
    • Locations
      • Jumaa Locations
      • Full-Time Islamic Schools
      • Part-Time Islamic Schools
      • Hifz Programs
      • Iftar Locations
      • Taraweeh Prayers
      • I'tikaf Locations
      • Eid Prayers
      • Eid Festival Locations
      • Camps Locations
    • Rentals
      • Add Rental
    • Find a Place
    • Find a Tenant
  • Opportunities
  • Locations
  • Rentals
  • Blog
  • Action Alerts
  • Home
  • Islamic Finance
  • Behind the Goldman Sachs sukuk debate
Behind the Goldman Sachs sukuk debate
18
Aug
2012

Behind the Goldman Sachs sukuk debate

Written by  Ismail Barreh
Published in Islamic Finance
  • Add to Facebook
  • Like this? Tweet it to your followers!

When Goldman Sachs announced last October that it planned to issue an Islamic bond, debate ignited over whether conventional banks in the West should be allowed to engage in Islamic finance.

The investment bank said it planned to issue a sukuk worth as much as $2 billion based on murabaha, a structure that instead of interest (which is banned by Islamic principles) uses a cost-plus-profit arrangement to pay investors. Some Islamic finance analysts however, questioned whether the underlying structure of the sukuk was really murabaha.

They suggested Goldman might use the proceeds to fund interest-based banking activities. They also said the sukuk might violate a ban against pure monetary speculation if it traded between investors on the Irish Stock Exchange, where it would be registered, at levels other than par value.

In fact, Abu Dhabi Islamic Bank's Shariah board rejected Goldman Sachs's proposed $2bn sukuk programme as unacceptable for Islamic investment. ADIB has the most prominent Islamic finance scholars on its board including Sheikh Mohammed Usmani Taqi.

.

At a major conference of Islamic scholars and bankers in London last February, much of the public and private discussion was devoted to whether growing Western interest in Islamic finance could damage the industry by compromising its religious principles. Some participants argued investment banks such as Goldman should be banned from issuing Islamic bonds, or sukuk, because the funds they raised could help to finance other parts of their business that did not comply with sharia or Islamic law.

“A conventional bank, with the exception of multilateral development banks like the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank, should not be allowed to issue sukuk,” said Badlisyah Abdul Ghani, chief executive of CIMB Islamic, the Islamic unit of CIMB Group, Malaysia's second biggest bank.

Supporters of the Goldman Sachs sukuk argue that we should focus on the transaction, not the bank.

“The fact that these sukuk are issued by Goldman Sachs or by another Western bank really makes no difference whatsoever as far as judgement of Sharia is concerned,” Mohamed Elgari, a prominent Islamic scholar, said at the February conference.

The debate could affect Western access to a fast-growing area of the financial world. Estimated at over $100 billion, global sukuk issuance is still dwarfed by trillions of dollars worth of conventional bonds. Nevertheless, the potential wealth locked up in oil-rich Gulf states offers rich enticement for conventional banks. HSBC established the Amanah Islamic Finance brand in 1998 and Deutsche Bank, Citi, UBS and Barclays quickly followed, all offering interest-free products for wealthy Gulf investors.

Basics of sukuk

.

Sukuk is popularly understood as an Islamic or Sharia-compliant “bond” whilst it is in fact an asset-backed trust certificate. In its simplest form sukuk is a certificate evidencing ownership of an asset, or the right to enjoy it. Sovereign states are the main issuers of sukuk and use funds raised to support infrastructure projects. The sukuk structures rely on the creation of a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV). The SPV would issue sukuk certificates that represent, for example the ownership of an asset, entitlement to a debt or to rental incomes, or even accumulation of returns from various sukuk (a hybrid sukuk).

Returns on sukuk

The return provided to sukuk holders therefore comes in the form of profit from a sale, rental or a combination of both. Sukuk could be based on mudaraba , musharaka, murabaha, salam, istisna, ijara or hybrid of these.

Difference between conventional bonds & sukuk

In its simplest form, a bond is a contractual debt obligation whereby the issuer must repay borrowed money with interest at fixed intervals.

.

In comparison, sukuk holders each hold an undivided beneficial ownership in the underlying assets. Consequently, sukuk holders are entitled to share in the revenues generated by the sukuk assets as well as being entitled to share in the proceeds of the realisation of the sukuk assets.

Sukuk issuance has proven its resilience during recent periods of turbulence in global capital markets. Sukuk issuance increased from US$ 14.9 billion in 2008 to US$ 23.3 billion in 2009, with Asia showing particular strength. Even so, the sukuk market is still a niche one, with huge potential for growth. The sukuk growth rate is currently 10-15 per cent in global financial markets

Are sukuks Islamic?

“About 85 percent of the Gulf Islamic sukuk do not comply with Sharia law,” says Sheikh Muhammad Taqi Usmani, an Islamic finance expert and head of a Bahrain-based regulatory institution that sets standards for the global industry.

In his ruling last year, Sheikh Taqi Usmani noted two flaws in current sukuk practices: the risk is not shared and reward is not shared according to the actual venture proceeds; and sukuk investors are shielded from the actual consequences of their investments.

.

Virtually all sukuk issued today guarantee the return of principal to the holders at maturity, in exactly the same way as conventional bonds. This is accomplished by means of a binding promise from either the issuer or the manager to repurchase the assets represented by the sukuk at the stated price at which these were originally purchased by the sukuk holders at the beginning of the process -- regardless of their true or market value at maturity.

An Islamic Goldman sukuk?

Goldman insists its planned sukuk obeys Islamic principles and will not be used to raise money for interest-based activities. But for many investors, the U.S. investment bank is synonymous with controversy.

“A great vampire squid wrapped around the face of humanity, relentlessly jamming its blood funnel into anything that smells like money” is how Rolling Stone reporter Matt Taibbi famously described Goldman Sachs.

The investment bank was last year charged for its key role in the US financial crisis. The US Department of Justice dropped the criminal case this month for lack of evidence, but the company is embroiled in yet another scandal. Sergey Aleynikov, former Goldman Sachs computer programmer, took with him the bank's secret, rapid-fire, stock-and commodities-trading software called “Doomsday Machine” when he left the company. Goldman Sachs is now suing the 39-year old engineer and tells the US government that there is a danger that somebody who knew how to use this program could use it to manipulate markets in unfair ways (causing one to wonder how Goldman itself uses that information)

.

The bank's “vampire squid” reputation and its connection with greed, concealment techniques, speculation and aggressive financial engineering don't gel with the Islamic finance ethos. Islamic finance stands against earning of money through unfair trading practices and other activities. As commentators have pointed out, such associations don't augur well for the integrity of Islamic finance.

There is also a need for greater regulation and close scrutiny for sukuk issues. Considering the noble objective of Islamic finance, the market has to move away from ribawi (interest-based) elements or interest-based products in order to achieve equitable distribution among the partners. The goal of Islamic finance is not to replicate in its entirety the conventional financial system. Emphasis should be placed on innovation that encourages and favours investments and funding that adheres to Shariah principles.

Ismail Barreh holds an MBA and a certificate in Islamic finance.  

This article was produced exclusively for Muslim Link and should not be copied without prior permission from the site. For permission, please write to info@muslimlink.ca.

Read 13226 times Last modified on Wed, 18 Apr 2018 08:14
Rate this item
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
(0 votes)
Tagged under
  • Islamic Finance
  • Investments
  • Shariah Compliant

Ismail Barreh

Latest from Ismail Barreh

  • Scholar shortage threatens Islamic financing industry Scholar shortage threatens Islamic financing industry
  • The outlook for Islamic finance in Africa The outlook for Islamic finance in Africa
  • Islamic finance a progenitor of venture capital Islamic finance a progenitor of venture capital

Related items

  • Community Responses to the Passing of Canadian Pioneer of Islamic Finance Pervez Nasim Community Responses to the Passing of Canadian Pioneer of Islamic Finance Pervez Nasim
  • Advancing the Halal Lifestyle Industry in North America: Halal Expo Canada 2024 May 8 -9 Advancing the Halal Lifestyle Industry in North America: Halal Expo Canada 2024 May 8 -9
  • Expanding Access to Halal Financing to Help Muslims Buy Homes in Alberta Expanding Access to Halal Financing to Help Muslims Buy Homes in Alberta
back to top
.
.
.
.
.

Subscribe to Mailing List

Sign up for our free Muslim Link Snapshot and get our events listing and latest articles sent to your inbox weekly.

Please enter a name
Please enter a valid email address
Please enter a city

Ottawa Events
View More Events
Assunnah Muslim Association Eid Al Adha Festival
Fri, Jun 06, 2025 02:00pm EST/EDT
Festivals
Ottawa Eagles Wrestling SUMMER Program - 16+ Grappling Program
Sat, Jun 07, 2025 all day
Courses
Online Event
Muslim Legal Support Centre (MLSC) Workplace Harassment: How to Recognize and Report It
Tue, Jun 10, 2025 06:00pm EST/EDT
Educational
Jami Omar Resume Mastering: Writing Resumes that Pass ATS
Wed, Jun 11, 2025 06:30pm EST/EDT
Educational
Centre islamique de l'Outaouais Eid Al Adha Festival
Sat, Jun 14, 2025 03:00pm EST/EDT
Festivals

Featured Articles

  • Calgary Eid al Adha Prayer Locations 2025 Calgary Eid al Adha Prayer Locations 2025
  • Greater Toronto Area Eid al Adha Prayer Locations 2025 Greater Toronto Area Eid al Adha Prayer Locations 2025
  • Ottawa Gatineau Eid al Adha Prayer Locations 2025 Ottawa Gatineau Eid al Adha Prayer Locations 2025

About us

  • About Muslim Link
    Our Team
    About Eye Media
    Contact Us
    Diversity & Inclusion Policy
  • Events & Directory Disclaimer
  • Project: A Muslim History of Ottawa

How To

  • How to Advertise on Muslim Link?
    How to View / Edit Your Advertisement Campaign?
    How to Add a Directory Listing on the Directory?
    How to Claim a Directory Listing?
    How to Add an Event?
    How to Add an Opportunity?
    How to Add a Rental Listing?

Event Listings

  •  - Ottawa
  •  - Toronto GTA
  •  - Montreal
  •  - Edmonton
  •  - Calgary
  •  - Vancouver
  •  - London
  •  - Windsor
  •  - Hamilton
  •  - Kitchener/Waterloo
  •  - Halifax
  •  - Winnipeg
  •  - Kingston
  •  - Regina/Saskatoon

Business & Community Directory

  •  - Ottawa
  •  - Toronto GTA
  •  - Montreal
  •  - Edmonton
  •  - Calgary
  •  - Vancouver
  •  - London
  •  - Windsor
  •  - Hamilton
  •  - Kitchener/Waterloo
  •  - Halifax
  •  - Winnipeg
  •  - Kingston
  •  - Regina/Saskatoon

Advertisers

  • Advertise Online
  • Become a Patron
  • Sponsorships
  • Join Snapshot e-Newsletter
  • Snapshot Publishing Dates

ML Team

  • Writers Workshops
  • Content Policy
  • Staff Payment System
  • Join the team

Social Media

Follow us on our pages!

Facebook Twitter Youtube LinkedIn Pinterest

Copyright © 2025 Muslim Link. All Rights Reserved. All articles, photos, graphics and images on this site remain the copyright of Muslim Link, unless otherwise noted, and should not be copied without prior permission. Designed by Eye Media Solutions
Top
Copyright © Muslim Link. All articles, photos, graphics and images on this site remain the copyright of Muslim Link, unless otherwise noted, and should not be copied without prior permission. 2025 All rights reserved. Custom Design by Youjoomla.com